Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution by phgnomo

View this thread on steempeak.com
· @phgnomo ·
$0.79
Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution
#### Repository
https://github.com/utopian-io

#### Components
Add a new category for @utopian-io submissions called "new projects ideas"
As an alternative, the proposal below could also be achieved as dividing the "Suggestions" category in two subcategories: **Suggestions for projects in development** and **New projects ideas** 

#### Proposal Description

As stated on Utopian Guidelines:

> Suggestions detail potentially beneficial significant technical features / enhancements to an Open Source project.

As explained, the suggestions category is directed to Open Source Projects already in development.

But one common occurence i have seen among a lot of people (myself included), is that sometimes they have a good idea for a project but lack the proper abilities to make that idea happen (lack of coding skills for example, or don´t have any acquiantance that have the needed skills).

Then two scenarios usually happens:

1 - The person go on with his life, even forgetting over that idea that *might* have been a good one, and the idea is lost
2 - The person latches on that idea and don´t share it with anyone afraid that people will "steal" his idea.

On both cases (not all of them), a good idea that could have turned in something very useful for a lot of people is lost to the void.

@utopian-io ended up creating a whole new economy based around sharing (be it suggestions, coding, etc), and voluntary work being rewarded.

But as it is today, the "Suggestions" category only allows new ideas related to ongoing projects, but what if ideas for new projects could also be rewarded?

This would probably encourage more people to share an idea that he will probably never implement in his lifetime, and devs could have a list of new possibilities to start to work on, when looking for new projects to create.

#### Mockups / Examples
Let´s say i have an idea for a new Steem-based interface called "New Amazin Steemit UI".

I would proceed to post the Idea through @utopian-io, with details about the idea that should describe:

* What is the project idea
* How i think the project would work
* What i think is needed for the project
* What would be the benefits for the users if this project was implemented
* What this project have that others existing projects don´t do/do worst
* If possible, add images of anything related to the project idea

The @utopian-io moderators would then judge(score) the project based mainly on:

* Is the project idea original?
* Is the project idea well described?
* The project add anything of value?
* Is it possible to actually implement the project?
* How hard it would be to implement the project?

Some cut criteria could also be implemented to ignore totally useless ideas.

#### Benefits
The main question would be "Why not use the Suggestions category for this?"

The main actor that would take advantage of this separation would be devs looking to new projects ideas to work on.

The main reason is that it is pretty hard to cycle through posts published on steemit, and it would be even harder for a developer to go through the #ideas tag to find a new project to idea to work on, because it would be mixed with suggestions related to ongoing projects.

Within the new @utopian-io UI, this category could have its own page, allowing for devs to cycle throught this list of new project ideas, with a relevancy filter with higher rewarded ideas being put on the top.

Besides that, devs could also be allowed to indicate that they liked the idea and would be working on that new project, what would allow them to meet each other and work together.

#### GitHub Account
https://github.com/phbr
👍  , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
properties (23)
post_id60,996,825
authorphgnomo
permlinkadd-a-new-projects-ideas-section-as-a-possible-utopian-io-contribution
categoryutopian-io
json_metadata{"tags":["utopian-io","ideas","busy"],"links":["https:\/\/github.com\/utopian-io","\/@utopian-io","\/@utopian-io","\/@utopian-io","\/@utopian-io","\/trending\/ideas","\/@utopian-io","https:\/\/github.com\/phbr"],"community":"busy","users":["utopian-io"],"app":"busy\/2.5.6","format":"markdown","image":[]}
created2018-08-29 00:57:21
last_update2018-08-29 00:57:21
depth0
children5
net_rshares529,493,106,404
last_payout2018-09-05 00:57:21
cashout_time1969-12-31 23:59:59
total_payout_value0.678 SBD
curator_payout_value0.115 SBD
pending_payout_value0.000 SBD
promoted0.000 SBD
body_length3,652
author_reputation22,733,518,989,206
root_title"Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution"
beneficiaries[]
max_accepted_payout1,000,000.000 SBD
percent_steem_dollars10,000
author_curate_reward""
vote details (55)
@upvotebank ·
<center>UpvoteBank</center> | <center>Your upvote bank</center>
------------ | -------------
![__2.jpg](https://steemitimages.com/DQmfDxvv4NLs3knYT7B2mHgE5ArnkheNmDSLydKKTfBwokj/__2.jpg) | This post have been upvoted by the @UpvoteBank service. Want to know more and receive "free" upvotes click [here](https://steemit.com/steemit/@upvotebank/gzsr5aw6)
properties (22)
post_id60,996,836
authorupvotebank
permlink20180829t005736491z
categoryutopian-io
json_metadata{"tags":["comment"],"app":"steemjs\/comment"}
created2018-08-29 00:57:36
last_update2018-08-29 00:57:36
depth1
children0
net_rshares0
last_payout2018-09-05 00:57:36
cashout_time1969-12-31 23:59:59
total_payout_value0.000 SBD
curator_payout_value0.000 SBD
pending_payout_value0.000 SBD
promoted0.000 SBD
body_length354
author_reputation231,443,210,169,699
root_title"Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution"
beneficiaries[]
max_accepted_payout1,000,000.000 SBD
percent_steem_dollars10,000
@tykee ·
$3.20
Hello @phgnomo, Thank you for your contribution.

The structure on your contribution is nice, including the formatting language. All good but few typo
Thinking about the idea you shared; creating a new section or category for new project Idea is more of organizational issues which means it does not have any technicality of how the project should run but rather controlling the company initial aim.

There is a development category which new or existing open source project could be improved for implementation of new features/functions as well.

```But one common occurence i have seen among a lot of people (myself included), is that sometimes they have a good idea for a project but lack the proper abilities to make that idea happen (lack of coding skills for example, or don´t have any acquiantance that have the needed skills).```

Not every project owners have coding skills but the zeal to run and bring the project to life will make them take steps of getting devs to start up their project, do some little coding and bring the whole idea to improve properly on utopian.

Utopian has helped in the development of hundreds of projects if not thousands. 
I think you missed this section in the Utopian guidelines for suggestion category 
``` Suggestions are technical feature/enhancements that are of significant potential added-value to an Open Source project.```

Thank you once again, and looking forward to receive  technical suggestions from you:)

Your contribution has been evaluated according to [Utopian policies and guidelines](https://join.utopian.io/guidelines), as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.

To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post, [click here](https://review.utopian.io/result/7/44444424).

---- 
Need help? Write a ticket on https://support.utopian.io/. 
Chat with us on [Discord](https://discord.gg/uTyJkNm). 
[[utopian-moderator]](https://join.utopian.io/)
👍  , , , , , , ,
properties (23)
post_id61,029,329
authortykee
permlinkre-phgnomo-add-a-new-projects-ideas-section-as-a-possible-utopian-io-contribution-20180829t102352502z
categoryutopian-io
json_metadata{"links":["https:\/\/join.utopian.io\/guidelines","https:\/\/review.utopian.io\/result\/7\/44444424","https:\/\/support.utopian.io\/","https:\/\/discord.gg\/uTyJkNm","https:\/\/join.utopian.io\/"],"users":["phgnomo"],"app":"steemit\/0.1","tags":["utopian-io"]}
created2018-08-29 10:23:54
last_update2018-08-29 10:23:54
depth1
children3
net_rshares2,117,867,114,010
last_payout2018-09-05 10:23:54
cashout_time1969-12-31 23:59:59
total_payout_value2.437 SBD
curator_payout_value0.763 SBD
pending_payout_value0.000 SBD
promoted0.000 SBD
body_length1,952
author_reputation164,689,786,548,286
root_title"Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution"
beneficiaries[]
max_accepted_payout1,000,000.000 SBD
percent_steem_dollars10,000
author_curate_reward""
vote details (8)
@phgnomo ·
Looks like moderator comments improved a lot these times i haven´t sent any contribution... Good job!

Anyway, allow me to disagree on some points:

> creating a new section or category for new project Idea is more of organizational issues which means it does not have any technicality of how the project should run but rather controlling the company initial aim.

I disagree here because this suggestion is related to user interface/interaction, not controlling the company.

A reorganization of categories have a direct influence on how both kind of users use the platform, by having two separate categories for different kinds of ideas.

>Not every project owners have coding skills but the zeal to run and bring the project to life will make them take steps of getting devs to start up their project, do some little coding and bring the whole idea to improve properly on utopian.

Ok, you have a point here, but i forgot to mention that some people might have a good idea for a project, but don´t want or don´t have the time to create and manage an open-source project, but have an interesting idea that could be used by other people willing to take that idea and make it happen.

But if there is no incentive to share that idea, they probably won´t do it, so a lot of ideas is lost to the void.

On the other hand, there is probably some devs that are looking for new ideas to work on, but don´t have any proper way to look for new ideas.

By dividing the Suggestions category between Ongoing projects/New projects, and having an specific filter on the New Projects ideas section would create a bridge between people that want to share an idea, and devs looking to start a new project.

> Suggestions are technical feature/enhancements that are of significant potential added-value to an Open Source project.

I didn´t missed that guideline, but i see this as a technical feature/enchancement on the @utopian-io frontend, adding value to @utopian project by creating the bridge between different kind of users of the platform.

So, consider my arguments above, and if possible, reevaluate my suggestion.

Thank you!
properties (22)
post_id61,038,785
authorphgnomo
permlinkre-tykee-re-phgnomo-add-a-new-projects-ideas-section-as-a-possible-utopian-io-contribution-20180829t125753969z
categoryutopian-io
json_metadata{"tags":["utopian-io"],"users":["utopian-io","utopian"],"app":"steemit\/0.1"}
created2018-08-29 12:57:51
last_update2018-08-29 12:57:51
depth2
children1
net_rshares0
last_payout2018-09-05 12:57:51
cashout_time1969-12-31 23:59:59
total_payout_value0.000 SBD
curator_payout_value0.000 SBD
pending_payout_value0.000 SBD
promoted0.000 SBD
body_length2,120
author_reputation22,733,518,989,206
root_title"Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution"
beneficiaries[]
max_accepted_payout1,000,000.000 SBD
percent_steem_dollars10,000
@tykee ·
```I disagree here because this suggestion is related to user interface/interaction, not controlling the company.```

Your idea is not just for the interface/interaction; it will also have an effect on the principles and process of the organization.

```Ok, you have a point here, but i forgot to mention that some people might have a good idea for a project, but don´t want or don´t have the time to create and manage an open-source project, but have an interesting idea that could be used by other people willing to take that idea and make it happen.```

You missed another part of Utopian aim which is to **empower professionals in their contribution to open source movement**. Utopian does not reward random abstract ideas.
If anyone has any idea and doesn't have time to run it or make it happen then the idea must be more than worthless. 
When we all see how great innovations are taking over the world.

```But if there is no incentive to share that idea, they probably won´t do it, so a lot of ideas is lost to the void.```
I think such ideas should go void because it does not go inline with the aim and objective of Utopian.
The negative part of this could be.
Create a mobile app that can fly like a bird.
An android phone should have fan or anything. 

```By dividing the Suggestions category between Ongoing projects/New projects, and having an specific filter on the New Projects ideas section would create a bridge between people that want to share an idea, and devs looking to start a new project.```

There is another category for task request which projects owner will state the feature and improvement he/she would like to do on his project via Utopian which devs will take the task up, get it done and get rewarded by Utopian. isn't that cool?

There is no way to manage the idea on Utopian.......Thank you!!!
👍  
properties (23)
post_id61,057,148
authortykee
permlinkre-phgnomo-re-tykee-re-phgnomo-add-a-new-projects-ideas-section-as-a-possible-utopian-io-contribution-20180829t170654529z
categoryutopian-io
json_metadata{"tags":["utopian-io"],"app":"steemit\/0.1"}
created2018-08-29 17:07:03
last_update2018-08-29 17:07:03
depth3
children0
net_rshares13,077,783,478
last_payout2018-09-05 17:07:03
cashout_time1969-12-31 23:59:59
total_payout_value0.000 SBD
curator_payout_value0.000 SBD
pending_payout_value0.000 SBD
promoted0.000 SBD
body_length1,829
author_reputation164,689,786,548,286
root_title"Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution"
beneficiaries[]
max_accepted_payout1,000,000.000 SBD
percent_steem_dollars10,000
author_curate_reward""
vote details (1)
@utopian-io ·
$0.02
Thank you for your review, @tykee!

So far this week you've reviewed 4 contributions. Keep up the good work!
👍  ,
properties (23)
post_id61,072,389
authorutopian-io
permlinkre-re-phgnomo-add-a-new-projects-ideas-section-as-a-possible-utopian-io-contribution-20180829t102352502z-20180829t211508z
categoryutopian-io
json_metadata{"app":"beem\/0.19.42"}
created2018-08-29 21:15:09
last_update2018-08-29 21:15:09
depth2
children0
net_rshares16,866,168,155
last_payout2018-09-05 21:15:09
cashout_time1969-12-31 23:59:59
total_payout_value0.019 SBD
curator_payout_value0.004 SBD
pending_payout_value0.000 SBD
promoted0.000 SBD
body_length108
author_reputation152,913,012,544,965
root_title"Add a "new projects ideas" section as a possible utopian-io contribution"
beneficiaries[]
max_accepted_payout1,000,000.000 SBD
percent_steem_dollars10,000
author_curate_reward""
vote details (2)