This is venomnymous, lol, is that so you can keep your personality disorders straight as to which one made which video?...lol.

You can eat any size pumpkin though pie pumpkins are supposedly grown to be somewhat sweeter their actual purpose to being so small is they provide just enough pumpkin for a couple pumpkin pies, maybe enough left for some pumpkin bread.  I actually prefer a larger pumpkin as if you are going to puree to freeze for holiday use you only have to cut and clean one large pumpkin to provide for all your winter holiday use.  

If you've never made pumpkin pies from scratch you don't know what you are missing, the taste is exceptional compared to store bought.  My family can't get enough of my pumpkin bread either, it's become a high demand item at family gatherings.  Last year was my first attempt at pumpkin rolls but despite the design shortcomings they were still gobbled up.  

Don't forget to gently  turn your pumpkin so that all sides ripen pretty equally.